All posts tagged: Wine Intelligence

Models vs. Reality, Part 1

Wine appreciation requires language. But the way you use language depends on what you consider to be a “good tasting note.” What is good? What’s the norm? …writing is a learned activity, no different in that regard from hitting a golf ball or playing the piano. Yes, some people naturally do it better than others. But apart from a few atypical autodidacts (who exist in all disciplines), there’s no practical way to learn to write, hit a golf ball, or play the piano without guidance on many points, large and small. And everyone, even the autodidact, requires considerable effort and practice in learning the norms. The norms are important even to those who ultimately break them to good effect. Bryan A. Garner, Garner’s Modern American Usage (2009, p. 104) Famous critics and formal tasting systems provide models/norms/reference points. But how good are those norms? What does “green apple, citrus peel, medium+ acidity” mean, exactly? Models are useful, but only if we don’t lose touch with what is actually going on. So let’s calibrate our models to reality. …